France Tenant Rights: Protected Tenant Status Under Loi 89-462

The Loi n°89-462 du 6 juillet 1989 (commonly known as the Loi Mermaz) is the central statute that protects tenants in France whose rented property is their résidence principale (principal residence). Among its most important provisions are the rules that protect certain categories of tenants from termination — providing what is sometimes called “locataire protégé” status. This article explains the rules, who qualifies, and what landlords must do to terminate the tenancy of a protected tenant lawfully.

1. The Statute — Loi 89-462

Loi 89-462 organises the residential lease into three regimes (bail nu, bail meublé, bail mobilité) and lays down a comprehensive code of tenant rights. Of particular importance:

• Article 10 — minimum lease term (3 years for individual landlord, 6 for legal entity).
• Article 15-I — landlord’s right to terminate at end of term.
• Article 15-III — special protection for older or low-income tenants.
• Article 17-2 — rules on rent (encadrement des loyers).

Source — Loi 89-462: https://www.legifrance.gouv.fr/loda/id/JORFTEXT000000509310

2. The General Rule — Termination at End of Term

Under Loi 89-462 art. 15-I, a landlord can terminate the lease at the end of the term only for one of three reasons:

• Reprise — the landlord (or a close family member listed in the article) wishes to occupy the property as their principal residence.
• Vente — the landlord wishes to sell the property unoccupied. In this case, the tenant has a right of first refusal (droit de préemption).
• Motif légitime et sérieux — a legitimate and serious reason, e.g., repeated unpaid rent, breach of contract, or antisocial behaviour.

The notice period is:

• 6 months for bail nu.
• 3 months for bail meublé.

The notice must specify the reason and, for reprise, identify the family member who will occupy.

3. The Protected Tenant — Article 15-III

Loi 89-462 art. 15-III provides that the landlord cannot terminate the lease against a tenant who:

• is aged 65 or over (at the date the notice would take effect); and
• has annual resources below a threshold linked to the plafonds PLUS for the area (modeste threshold);

unless the landlord:

• offers a suitable rehousing in the same neighbourhood (within the commune or a 5km radius in dense urban areas), corresponding to the tenant’s needs and resources; or
• is themselves over 65 or in a similar low-income situation.

This is the cornerstone of “locataire protégé” status — protection from non-renewal even if the landlord has a legitimate reprise reason.

4. The Resource Threshold

The annual resource threshold for protected tenant status is set by reference to the plafonds PLUS — the upper limit for social housing eligibility — for the relevant geographic zone. The thresholds vary by family composition.

For a single person in zone tendue Paris in 2026, the plafond PLUS is approximately €25,500/year (subject to annual revision).

Resources are computed using the same methodology as for income tax — net taxable income from the previous year (revenu fiscal de référence). The tenant must provide their avis d’imposition to evidence eligibility.

Source — Service-public.fr on protected tenants: https://www.service-public.fr/particuliers/vosdroits/F1168

5. The Rehousing Obligation

If the tenant qualifies as protected, the landlord must offer:

• A property in the same commune (or close radius — typically up to 5 km in zones tendues, 10 km elsewhere).
• Suitable to the tenant’s needs (size adequate for the household).
• Suitable to the tenant’s resources (rent within the tenant’s affordability).
• Compliant with the same lease regime (bail nu replaced by bail nu).

If no suitable rehousing offer is made, the notice is invalid and the lease is automatically renewed.

6. Joint Tenants and Family Members

The protection extends to:

• The named tenant.
• A spouse or PACS partner who has notified the landlord.
• A cohabitating partner (“concubin”) if the situation has lasted at least one year (Code de la construction et de l’habitation art. L.353-21).

The age and resource test is applied to the tenant or the tenant’s partner — whichever provides the protection. If both qualify, both are protected.

7. Notice — Form and Substance

A notice of non-renewal must:

• Be served by bailiff (huissier de justice) or registered letter with proof of receipt or physical handover with signed acknowledgement (Loi 89-462 art. 15-I).
• Specify the reason — reprise (with named beneficiary), vente, or motif légitime et sérieux.
• Be given at least 6 months (bail nu) or 3 months (bail meublé) before the term ends.
• For reprise, the named beneficiary must take up occupation within 6 months of the tenant leaving.

For sale (vente), the notice must specify the price and conditions and must offer the property to the tenant first under the droit de préemption (right of first refusal).

8. What Happens If a Protected Tenant’s Notice is Defective?

If the notice is found defective by the tribunal judiciaire (chambre des baux):

• The lease is renewed automatically for a new term of 3 (or 6) years for bail nu, or 1 year for bail meublé.
• The tenant retains their existing rights including the resource and age protection.
• The landlord may have to pay damages if the defect was not in good faith.

9. Protection During the Lease — Not Just at Termination

In addition to termination protection, the protected tenant has:

• Rent ceiling — under encadrement des loyers in qualifying zones (Paris and others), rent increases are capped at the IRL index annually (Loi 89-462 art. 17-2).
• Repair obligation — the landlord is responsible for “décence” (sanitary fitness) under Loi 89-462 art. 6 and Décret n°2002-120.
• Diagnostic disclosure — DPE, lead, asbestos, and risk reports must be provided.
• Surface area honesty — penalty for overstatement above 5% (Loi 89-462 art. 3-1).

10. The DPE Restriction — Climate Law 2021

Under the Loi Climat et Résilience 2021 (art. 160), residential leases of properties with poor energy performance are progressively banned:

For an existing lease in a banned property, the landlord cannot renew the lease beyond the relevant date. This effectively forces an unwilling termination — but if the tenant is protected, the rehousing obligation still applies, creating practical difficulties for landlords with G-rated portfolios.

11. Common Mistakes — Gyoseishoshi View

• Not checking tenant’s age and resources before serving notice. Verify with the avis d’imposition. If the tenant is protected, plan rehousing first.
• Assuming a rural location escapes the rehousing obligation. It does not — the obligation is to offer a property in the same commune or close radius.
• Forgetting the named beneficiary’s 6-month occupation. If the landlord serves notice claiming reprise for, say, their daughter, but the daughter does not actually occupy, the tenant can sue for damages and reinstatement.
• Using a 6-month notice for bail meublé. The notice for bail meublé is 3 months. Using 6 months is simply too long; using 3 months for bail nu is too short.
• Failing to offer the droit de préemption on a sale. The tenant has a 2-month window to accept the price offered. Skipping this step renders the sale voidable.
• Increasing rent at end of term over the IRL. In zones tendues, rent on renewal is capped at the IRL index. Above that, the increase is unenforceable.
• Treating a sub-tenant as a tenant. A subtenant has no direct protection against the head landlord under Loi 89-462; only the head tenant is protected.

12. The Tenant’s Side — How to Assert Protection

A tenant served with a notice of non-renewal should:

• Verify the notice form is correct.
• Check the date — minimum notice period must be observed.
• If protected, send a registered letter to the landlord asserting article 15-III protection, attaching the avis d’imposition.
• If no suitable rehousing is offered within the notice period, assert renewal of the lease.
• If pressed, contact ANIL/ADIL for free legal information.

Source — ADIL (free housing legal information): https://www.anil.org/

13. The MmowW Scrib🐮 Workflow

Cell #9 (FR Lease) generates:

• A bail nu / bail meublé / bail mobilité tailored to the tenant’s profile.
• A diagnostic dossier (DPE, lead, asbestos, risk).
• A notice of non-renewal (for landlord side) tailored to the chosen reason.
• A protection-status response template (for tenant side).
• A rehousing offer template that complies with article 15-III requirements.

Each step is gated by the prerequisite verifications (DPE rating, surface honesty, deposit cap, diagnostic dossier).

14. The Bigger Picture

The protected tenant rules are part of a broader French policy goal — to prevent older and low-income tenants from being displaced from urban centres. Critics argue the rules effectively trap landlords with long-term unmovable tenants; supporters see them as a humane brake on gentrification. Whichever view one takes, the rules are clear and enforceable, and a landlord who ignores them will lose the case.

For tenants, the protection is real but conditional on documentation. Keeping a current avis d’imposition and being responsive to lease correspondence is essential to assert the right at the right moment.

Build your French lease pack with Scrib🐮

¥22,000/month pass for unlimited access to all 18 document types across 7 countries — including bail nu/meublé/mobilité, diagnostic dossier, and protected tenant assessment. Start Free Preview →

Disclaimer

This article provides legal information, not legal advice. MmowW Scrib🐮 is a document preparation service operated by a licensed Gyoseishoshi (行政書士) office in Japan. We are not avocats, notaires, or experts-comptables.

Sources

• Loi n°89-462 du 6 juillet 1989: https://www.legifrance.gouv.fr/loda/id/JORFTEXT000000509310
• Service-public.fr — fin du bail: https://www.service-public.fr/particuliers/vosdroits/F1168
• Service-public.fr — locataire protégé: https://www.service-public.fr/particuliers/vosdroits/F920
• ANIL (Agence nationale pour l’information sur le logement): https://www.anil.org/